Find Misconceptions Earlier with Knowledge Checks and AI Tutor for Imagine IM

Imagine IM

Use student results to plan targeted support and provide personalized, curriculum-based guidance before lessons 

Knowledge Checks help teachers identify misconceptions before instruction and use those insights to plan targeted support. Based on each student’s results, AI Tutor then provides personalized, curriculum-based guidance to address misconceptions and build understanding before the lesson begins. Learn more in the Imagine ClassMate Help Center or by watching the video.

New for Back to School ’26

Imagine Plus Math

Personalized math practice, intervention, enrichment, and live tutoring in English and Spanish 

Imagine+ Math is a new K–8 supplemental solution designed to help your students build grade-level math skills and extend their learning. Assessment-driven pathways, customizable assignments, and On-Demand Tutoring in English and Spanish support targeted instruction and real-time help. Preview the Implementation Guide to plan for successful use. 

Learn More
Imagine Plus Math Implementation Guide

August 5, 2026 8:00 am

Imagine Learning Acquires Wayside Publishing to Advance World Language Education

Acquisition strengthens Imagine Learning’s portfolio of high-quality instructional materials and broadens its support for preparing students for success beyond graduation.

Tempe, AZ — August 5, 2026 — Imagine Learning today announced the acquisition of Wayside Publishing, a leading provider of world language curriculum and language-learning solutions. The acquisition broadens Imagine Learning’s world language offerings with proficiency-based curriculum that helps schools develop the academic foundations, communication skills, and cultural understanding students need in an increasingly connected world.

Imagine Learning has long helped K–12 educators develop students’ academic knowledge alongside the critical thinking, communication, and problem-solving skills essential for success beyond the classroom. World language education advances that work by giving students authentic opportunities to communicate across cultures, consider new perspectives, and apply what they learn in meaningful contexts.

For more than 35 years, Wayside has been at the forefront of proficiency-based world language education, helping educators develop confident communicators and globally minded learners. Its Spanish, French, German, Latin, and Italian programs pair research-based curriculum and authentic language experiences with Nualang, its AI-powered language-learning companion. Together, these resources create an instructional experience centered on meaningful communication rather than memorization.

“Preparing students for the future requires more than academic achievement alone,” said Jonathan Grayer, Founder and CEO of Imagine Learning. “Students need to communicate across cultures, solve complex problems, collaborate with diverse teams, and adapt to a rapidly changing world. World language education develops those capabilities in ways few other disciplines can, and Wayside has spent more than three decades helping educators bring that learning to life.”

“Wayside has always believed exceptional language instruction opens doors for students — to new cultures, new perspectives, and new opportunities,” said Meghann Gorden, CEO of Wayside Publishing. “Joining Imagine Learning gives us the opportunity to accelerate that mission with a partner that shares our commitment to instructional excellence and innovation. Together, we will continue supporting the educators and schools that made Wayside a trusted leader in world language education.”

With Wayside, Imagine Learning broadens the ways it supports districts in preparing students for success in school, careers, and life while bringing an established world language portfolio to more educators and learners.

About Imagine Learning

 
About Imagine Learning 
Imagine Learning supports educators with curriculum and learning solutions designed to improve student outcomes. Serving students in more than half the districts nationwide, the company delivers a portfolio of core curriculum, courseware, supplemental solutions, assessment, and school services, combining high-quality curriculum, actionable insights, and instructional support to help districts make measurable progress.

Learn More

Breaking the Cycle of Math Anxiety

Listen on Spotify
Listen on Apple Podcasts

Hillary Rinaldi on Why Math Anxiety Is a Systems Issue

In this Heart Work special, Lauren is joined by National Math Improvement Project director Hillary Rinaldi to look at the big picture and discuss why math anxiety must be addressed at a systems-wide level. Drawing on work with some of the nation’s largest school districts, Hillary shares what’s working, what still needs to change, and why community may be one of the most powerful tools for improving math outcomes nationwide.

From Imagine Learning, I’m Lauren Keeling, and you’re listening to Heart Work, an honest profile of America’s educators.

Hillary Rinaldi: It takes teachers learning alongside their students to teach differently. What I’ve never understood is this idea that if you say that you hated math in school, that then you also want kids now to learn it in the same way that you learned it. 

Lauren Keeling: I think the first thing we’ll start with, Hillary, is if you could just give us your Hillary Rinaldi elevator pitch. Tell us who you are, what you do, what your interest is. 

Hillary: I’m Hillary Rinaldi, Vice President at Whiteboard Advisors, focused on K–12 research and strategy. Whiteboard Advisors is an education policy firm. We work across early childhood through workforce development. 

I have the joy and privilege of working pretty exclusively in the K–12 space. Part of that work also includes leading the National Math Improvement Project, which I’m really excited to share more about today. The National Math Improvement Project is a community of practice of six of the largest districts in the country, all focused on improving math outcomes for students. 

We are in formal year three for the National Math Improvement Project. This includes six of the largest high-poverty districts in the country, so that includes New York, LA, Chicago, Miami, Houston, and Philadelphia. 

We convene three times a year in person, and then we host virtual meetings monthly. Those meetings and conversations are all focused around our three core challenges. 

As we think about districts of this size and thinking about scale, they’re representative of 2.5 million students, and so when we talk about how we scale high-quality instructional materials and ensure every student is getting high-quality instruction, what does that look like? What does that mean to tackle?  

Second, how do we support our teachers and leaders in building their professional learning in both pedagogy and practice around mathematics? And third, building math mindset for our students and community. I think that is a critical piece of the math anxiety puzzle that we’re all grappling with. 

So I’m excited to talk more about not just math anxiety, but maybe how we can quell some of those concerns and what our district leaders are doing so well. 

On the Whiteboard side, I do a lot of work with state leaders around math as well. Prior to Whiteboard, I was the Deputy Chief of Staff at the Tennessee Department of Education, where I worked closely on our accountability system and our high-quality instructional materials adoption process. So I certainly bring the state lens into this work, while also seeing how districts are responsible for ensuring learning is happening every day. Even as states are grappling with changes to math standards or what happens next, districts are, in many ways, leading the charge on how we reimagine math and ensure that maybe there’s less phobia for the next generation. 

Lauren:  It sounds like excellent work. All of the words that you just said have been sources of and remedies to math anxiety for students as individuals, classrooms, grade levels, districts, schools, and systems altogether. 

So I’m excited to talk a little bit about that. To start, when people hear math anxiety, what we have come to understand is that they often think about their own experience, or they think about an individual student. But our wonder today is how much of it is actually something that’s produced by the system the student is existing in? 

Hillary: Just a casual question to start with. 

Lauren: Yeah, easy (laughs). 

Hillary: I appreciate the question, Lauren. So I think, even, what do we mean by math anxiety? I think it comes from a place of the rhetoric around, “I’m not a math person,” right? 

What does that mean? Where does that come from? When did we decide as a society that it’s OK to not be a math person? And I think some of that is an assumption that math is what you experienced in school, right? I’m going to steal a quote from Dr. Afi Wiggins from the [Charles A.] Dana Center, who says, “Math is the language of the universe.” So this idea that you can opt out of participating in math just doesn’t make sense, and it also doesn’t give us credit for how we use math every day. 

So when we say, what does the system produce, I think what we know now about how brains function and how kids can learn math can both look different than it did when you and I were sitting in desks in rows, and that also means it takes teachers learning alongside their students to teach differently. 

What I’ve never understood is this idea that if you say that you hated math in school, that then you also want kids now to learn it in the same way that you learned it. Let’s not keep repeating the same mistakes, perhaps. 

Lauren: That’s an interesting and very deep point to make, Hillary, that oftentimes teachers say, “I hate math,” and then hold tightly to using those very math practices in their own classroom and resist trying new things like inquiry-based learning, for example. 

Hillary: Yeah, I would love to talk more about the inquiry-based model or just what we’re seeing, and I can use New York City Solves as an example as well. 

So New York City Solves is the New York City Public Schools’ system-wide approach to elevating math as both a priority and how they’re planning to support teachers and students in math, right? So this is complementary to New York City Reads. 

I think through New York City Solves, they identified specific shifts that they were making, and that is an intentional move away from a set of procedures and practices where it’s “I do, we do, you do,” and instead thinking about how we build in that sense of inquiry and discovery to be able to support students in actually solving problems, right? Because, yes, students need to understand basic facts and understand the standard algorithm, but what we really want is to have students be fluent in numeracy — to build their number sense — and to do that does, in fact, take a different approach than strictly procedural. We need to think about students building their procedural alongside conceptual, and I would also add spatial. 

Lauren: I love this because, as a kindergarten teacher, I only knew how to teach how I was taught. So learning, unlearning, and trying new practices was really an interesting kind of feel-forward for me. And I remember the very first math practice that was newly introduced to my district and myself: subitizing. And to hear tiny five-year-olds say the word subitizing or “I can subitize” was really eye-opening for me. It gave students who were typically resistant to, reserved in, or simply shut down during our normal math practices, the opportunity to think about math differently. Subitizing and thinking about math differently and explaining how I see those numbers or those shapes or that organization was really an interesting practice. 

So I think I’m just telling you that I really appreciate everything you just said, and it really resonated with me. 

Hillary: Thank you, Lauren. You’re not alone in being, especially an elementary teacher, that was not super excited to be teaching math, right? And the part of that is also a gap in our educator preparation programs of very little math practice of pedagogy is baked into our elementary ed coursework, right?  

I’m not pointing this failure as resting on ed prep programs. I think there are improvements that need to be made at each level, but it is true that — and with our work with six of the largest districts, as they are trying to build that competency especially among elementary teachers — it is both a different approach, and it’s unlikely that they are coming into the district prepared to teach strong pedagogical practices in math. 

Part of this comes from the adoption of high-quality instructional materials, right? As teachers are preparing to actually implement new materials with integrity, it takes more than just unboxing the new materials and more about when we say things like lesson internalization and all of that. 

All of those steps, to me, are quite simple. We need teachers to also be doing the math, right? And part of doing the math means that there’s more than one way to do it. And if there’s more than one way to do it, we have to give our students the ability to test and fail and replicate, and this idea that being fearful of making mistakes is the antithesis of math. 

Doing math inherently means that you are making mistakes and then solving for those. That’s not the problem. That’s actually the whole point. And I think where teachers, if we’re going to talk in generalities, like the challenge of the elementary teacher to release that cognitive load to their students is challenging because it’s not what you expected to be doing, maybe as a teacher, and it means you don’t always know exactly where the class is headed. 

I certainly prefer to have control in a situation, and I understand why teachers want that too, but we know that our students are going to be more successful if we give them that time and space to explore, not to be in an unproductive struggle, but how do we support all students and the scaffolds that we can bring in to make math both relevant and rigorous, but I think most importantly, enjoyable. 

Lauren: I’m going to say it wrong, but you said something really beautiful, which was that math is inherently designed as, we’re going to get it wrong, and we’re going to solve through it, and we’re going to make mistakes, which is a statement we don’t say out loud. Or at least when I was learning — it’s unfair for me to say that now — but as a student learning, no one ever said, “Math is designed for mistakes. Mistakes are how we learn, how we grapple, and how we move productively through learning.” 

So do you think that that’s an important statement to start saying out loud and start giving educators permission to honor that in their classrooms? 

Hillary: Absolutely. What’s more freeing than being able to say, “All right. I’m going to write something up on my whiteboard,” or more likely my SMART Board, right? And say, “Here’s a problem.” 

I was actually leading a virtual session yesterday, and we started with the question of “How would you approach the problem 201 minus 68?” Not a complex problem, but even that, we know there are multiple ways to solve it. 

So if I write it up there and I ask my class, “OK, what’s your approach?” I actually am not asking for the first kid that raises their hand with the correct answer. I want to know how you’re doing that, because if we’re building the skills to understand the how and the why, then you’re going to get to the what, right? 

But you also learn so much more about your kids, but then, as students are in those peer-to-peer and student discourses, to say, “Oh, I never thought of it that way,” right? 

I’m of the camp, I’m always looking for friendly numbers, right? So I’m going to make this 200 minus 70 and then take away the other three. But then I had someone else in my group who said, “I wrote it down, and I used the standard algorithm.” And I was like, “Oh, I never even considered picking up a pen to do that,” right? 

And so as you do that, that also releases the teacher from being the sole proprietor of knowledge, right? Student discourse is incredibly important, and I think the more we talk about building students’ durable skills or how states and districts are thinking about a portrait of a graduate and what it means to graduate from high school, what are the skills you’re bringing with you? 

There’s a natural opportunity to build that into math classrooms. Actually, there’s a paper that came out last summer by Student Achievement Partners about the connections between durable skills and mathematics, and I think it is really compelling because any math teacher will tell you, “Well, of course, we’re engaged in critical thinking and collaborating,” right? 

In the classrooms that are building those math skills, you’re naturally imbuing students with whatever label you want to put on them: the non-academic skills, the career-ready skills, the durable skills. Those things are happening, and so how do we give students more opportunities to demonstrate that? 

And that’s through providing them with the ownership of their learning and carrying the cognitive load of the math class. 

Lauren: Are you a Battelle for Kids person? 

Hillary: Of course! 

Lauren: OK, well, you’re saying all of the words that I know and hold dearly to my heart: durable skills, student achievement network, portrait of a graduate. 

Hillary: Yes. They put out a landscape review of different portraits of a graduate, and so I’ve used that in some other work as well. The XQ Institute also looked at different policies that impact high school and how we think about redesigning high school, and I think where those skills come into play is a big piece, but also thinking about things like competency-based learning and not just seat time as well. 

Yeah, but that could be a whole other… 

Lauren: Podcast topic. A whole other collection. I think we’ll have to spend some time there. 

Hillary: I agree. 

Lauren: Let’s talk about the National Math Improvement Project, and what we know is it’s bringing together districts from all around, and they are thinking about those system-wide challenges, right? Like educator capacity, leader capacity, math mindset. You said all of those things to us. Where does math anxiety sit in that work? 

Hillary: Unfortunately, I think math anxiety is kind of like the elephant in the room anytime you’re talking about math. I think within this group, we don’t talk about it as a problem. 

We are hopeful that as we do all of these things, a byproduct of this work is that math anxiety can disappear. And I think we’re actually starting to see that as we visit classrooms across our six districts. So each of our convenings, a different city hosts, and so we get to go into math classrooms everywhere and be able to see what’s happening in practice, right? 

Get beyond our district plans and priorities and say, “OK, but what does this really look like in a school in the Bronx, in a school in the South Side, in a school in Central LA?” To be able to see this work in action. 

And I can honestly say over the last three years, the more math classrooms I visit, the more instances I have conversations with students who say they really enjoy math class, that they’re having fun in math, that they like what they’re doing, or even if it’s not their favorite subject, they’re still very engaged in the work. 

And I think part of that is because of these shifts in pedagogy and practice where math is more engaging, right? Where it is students working in small groups or working with technology-enabled solutions that are really targeted to either catch them up or accelerate their learning. 

I think one of the things that we saw both in Miami-Dade, as well as LAUSD, was support for Algebra 1 and thinking outside the box. 

We know that too many students don’t pass Algebra 1 on the first try. I am certainly not the first person to say this, but I strongly concur that if you fail Algebra 1, your second attempt should not just be a louder, slower version of Algebra 1. That’s true for any intervention. 

And so what LAUSD did last summer with their Algebra 1 course is they actually used Prisms VR and put students in a virtual reality setting to engage in math in a not just procedural and conceptual, but also spatial reasoning. And when you’re connected to your body and seeing what’s happening, predicting the LA fires based on logarithmic functions or the erosion of the beach in Miami, it’s both checking those boxes of extremely relevant to the student, maintaining that rigor of aligned to standards, but also making it fun, right? 

And so LA saw the highest attendance rate for summer school last year and the highest pass rate, and now they’re going to expand it for this summer. 

It’s less about how we are addressing math anxiety head-on and more about how we are doing all of the other things that we know work in math, and that if we do that well, we believe that we will build the math mindset in our students, educators, and our community to then make that anxiety go away. 

Lauren:  So in a minute we’ll talk a little bit more about the great things that districts and leaders and teachers are doing to open up the classroom so that children are able to enjoy and engage in math joyfully and thoughtfully and really pull from the great work and the great changes that are being made. 

But I think in order to really talk robustly about the solutions, we need to understand the problem a little bit. Can you point to just some of the district-level decisions that commonly contribute to systems, classrooms, and districts that may be producing some math anxiety in students even when they don’t intend to? 

Hillary: Yes. I think if we flip the question and say, what are the things that are mitigating math anxiety, because I think that’s what our six districts are prioritizing, and a lot of the work that I think state leaders are prioritizing, as well. What are the conditions necessary to make those classrooms deliver on relevance, rigor, and joy? 

And so each of the six districts that are a part of the National Math Improvement Project has adopted and invested in high-quality instructional materials, right? They’re instructional materials that are pushing the practices that we know work, including a more inquiry-based model in most cases. And then the need to align both what’s happening in Tier 1 instruction along with intervention or high-impact tutoring, right? The student experience needs to be coherent across their school day to connect the dots between what they learned in one place and how they’re maybe addressing any gaps or accelerating to the next grade level too. And that work is incredibly difficult because of the system of master scheduling, right? How do you get students where they need to go, when, and based on what they know and what we need them to learn next? 

Houston ISD has done really interesting work in their approach with the New Education System under Superintendent Mike Miles to say every student is getting that intervention time that is either supporting skills that they have not yet mastered or advancing to the next set of skills as well. 

I think the teacher and leader training and true job-embedded professional development is one of the things that can’t be missed. And so in our recent report about year zero in your implementation of high-quality instructional materials, the NMIP profiled both New York City and the School District of Philadelphia, for both of those districts, this is the first time that they have been focused on narrowing the instructional materials that are being used. And instead of leaving it up to schools to determine what makes sense in their classrooms, they can instead rely on the district to make those decisions, to say, “We know that this is of high quality, and this is where your teacher should be focusing their time and attention.” 

And then, of course, the teacher is still the person who knows their classroom best. It doesn’t take away from the individuality of the teacher and those students because in your application of taking high-quality instructional materials and actually delivering on a lesson, you know where your students might need more support or how you’re building in those scaffolds for however many multilingual learners you might have in your class or students where you need to meet their IEPs. I think, spoiler alert, the best math scaffolds for a multilingual learner are going to be good scaffolds for any student in your class as well. And so I think there is a lot that we can be doing, and it can’t all fall to that third-grade teacher to figure it out all on her own to then be able to support students in thriving in math. 

Lauren:  So talking about coherence and you noted in curriculum intervention, tutoring, professional learning, all of those parts and pieces, how does, or why does coherence matter for student confidence, not just their achievement? 

Hillary: I joked earlier this year that coherence seems to be the word of 2026, and how we even define that gets muddled depending on the context. 

But when we talk about instructional coherence, it’s at every level. So there’s instructional coherence necessary at the system level so that your academics team and your schools team are speaking the same language. Instructional coherence at the school level, that the principal knows what to look for when we talk about what this experience looks like in the classroom, right? 

And then there’s the student experience of, what does coherence look like for that student? I think to your question, we’re talking about what instructional coherence looks like for a student in a system that’s getting it right. 

For a student that might be — let’s go to fifth-grade fractions, right? If I’m a fifth-grade teacher and I know I have a student who is struggling with mastering complex fractions, we know that that’s probably not the skill that’s being taught in fifth grade, right? That’s a skill that actually started as early as kindergarten, right? And we assessed it in third grade. So there are maybe some missing pieces there. What we don’t want is for that student to spend all their time in remediation and never actually get to grade-level content. 

The coherent system means that they have access to Tier 1 content by getting that just-in-time support during intervention or during tutoring, or both, to then be able to access that grade-level content, so you can be building on the grade-level skills and eventually catch up. 

I think that’s also a difference between how we approach intervention in literacy and intervention in math. Literacy is so linear. In math, there are places where we can catch up. 

I think there was a great analogy that Shalinee Sharma at Zearn used. If you’re watching a show, if we’re binge-watching Grey’s Anatomy and you jump in in Season 7 — well, you can jump in in Season 7, and they’re going to play the preview of the past six seasons of what you need to know to still be able to enjoy that episode — you’re not going know every detail, but that’s actually OK because we can get some of those other details as we catch up later.  

I actually am not sure what the original question was at this point, or where I can add. 

Lauren: No, that was great because I think it’s important to define coherence, right? So even just in — I did a presentation yesterday in Minnesota, and we talked deeply about coherence, and in that conversation, it was strictly at the teacher level. 

So in my classroom, I’m using the same instructional language as in Hillary’s classroom. She’s using the same instructional language. And the value of that moving students along the pathways — this was specifically for reading — but along the pathways of becoming students who can read and students who can read to learn. 

So I’m going jump ahead just a little bit because you pointed to it… 

Hillary: I know what I wanted to add, Lauren, on instructional leadership and building coherence. 

In the student experience for coherence, it also relies on the school, right, your whole school model being aligned. There’s a lot of work that we’re doing to support teacher pedagogy and practice in math. 

We also know that most principals do not come up from a math experience, and so there’s also a gap in knowledge there. And if we want our principals, or if it’s the assistant or the dean that is the instructional leader of the building, they need to know what to look for in math class as they’re doing those observations, right? 

If they’re coaching those teachers or you have a coach coming in, it’s really important that principals and instructional leaders are brought along to understand what it means when we are implementing new instructional materials and when we are addressing these shifts that support building a positive math mindset, because it’s very different, right? 

We would hope it looks different to go into math class now than it did 10 years ago, 20 years ago. Some of that connection doesn’t always happen. I think Chicago Public Schools has done a really excellent job in bringing their principals along so that they identify as, “I’m a math principal. I know what’s happening in math class in my school.” 

Lauren: That’s great, and that was actually the next question I was going to ask you, believe it or not, was about principals. So that’s perfect. I want to talk a little bit about access for a few minutes and think about how, of course, again, we’re focusing on or framing around math anxiety. 

How does math anxiety intersect with access? And when I ask that, what I mean is when we’re thinking about students who are encouraged to enter into Algebra 1, for example, and who are not encouraged to step into an Algebra 1 space. So let’s talk about how those things intersect. 

Hillary: Yes. So the National Math Improvement Project released a report last year about Algebra 1 access and success: Algebra 1: A Gateway, Not a Gatekeeper, right?  And because so much just does hinge on Algebra 1, it feels high stakes, and that’s because it is high stakes. It’s a strong predictor of your success in high school and that success beyond high school. So when we think about how we are supporting students in early access to Algebra 1, it also has to ensure that they are successful within Algebra 1. 

I’ll shout out to Chicago Public Schools and their work over the last 10 years to expand access while also maintaining the pass rates of success for students. They went from a version of access that meant, you know, if you looked at the demographics of the schools that had Algebra 1 in eighth grade, it was almost a perfect extrapolation of schools that were higher income and mostly white. 

At this point, almost 100 percent of middle schools have access to eighth-grade Algebra, and they’ve completely changed how they’re identifying students to be enrolled in eighth-grade Algebra. So while they also increased the N size of students that had access, they equally maintained the N size of the students who are demonstrating success, and that has disproportionately positively impacted students of low income and students who are non-white. 

That’s important because we know that if you want to pursue advanced math in high school and beyond, you really need to come into high school having mastered Algebra 1. 

Now, there are other pathways, and maybe you don’t need to take calculus in high school. Certainly, most students don’t need to take calculus in high school. But we shouldn’t be making that decision for students, right? We should be allowing them to have voice and choice in what they do, to then be prepared for the jobs of the future that we literally have no idea what they’re going to look like as we sit here in 2026 right now. 

I think the other work that’s been happening, not just in our districts, but at scale as states are pursuing more comprehensive math policy change, is automatic enrollment in advanced coursework. So we now have several states where if your end-of-year state summative assessment shows that you are mastering that math content or above grade level, then you’re going to be automatically enrolled in advanced math in the next year. This means that we’ve eliminated any potential implicit biases or recommendation function for those math classes, and so, again, it’s another way to increase access. 

Now, where the system has to catch up is if we know we’ve expanded access, we have more students that are pursuing advanced math, which is a huge win. That also means we have a wider range of students who are participating in those math courses, and teachers who have been used to teaching maybe the top 10 percent are now teaching the top 25 percent. That also requires shifts within pedagogy and practice to support all students who now have access and ensure that they are successful. 

Lauren: What are some of the challenges in that space? So I’m used to teaching the top 10 percent, now I’m teaching the top 25 percent. As an educator, what makes that difficult? 

Hillary: I think it’s what makes teaching the hardest and best job simultaneously, right? The 20-some students that are sitting in front of you, there is no average student, typical student. Each one is coming to you as an individual. They all have their strengths. They all have the things that they still need to work on. 

I think when you have a classroom with a wider range of abilities, which is just more universally true now because our students are coming in with more gaps than they have historically for myriad reasons, our teachers then need to be better supported to allow for differentiation, right? And how do we differentiate for a wider range of students and abilities? 

Again, this can’t all fall on the backs of teachers as we ask them to continue to do more with less. I personally think this is one of the ways that tech enablement and AI tools can really help within the classroom, not for what is student-facing, but for what can help teachers in reducing the administrative burden of teaching to free up their time and energy to do what they do best, which is that direct instruction to their students and meeting individual student needs. 

Lauren: Every teacher in the world just took a deep breath and cheered a little bit because I think that that’s what every educator wants is something to take up the administrative side, the logistical side of doing teaching and learning, so that they can focus on the good stuff, which is actually teaching and learning. 

We have also spoken to Peter Liljedahl about Building Thinking Classrooms, which was a fascinating experience, and I think the question that it points to is what system conditions need to be in place for that kind of really thinking-rich classroom, and then also to actually make it work at scale. 

Hillary: Right. So I think if we take the Building Thinking Classrooms idea, right, this is still high-quality instructional materials at the center, but really prioritizing student learning and building student competence. So I’d also point to other competency-based models or other learning opportunities that are agnostic to seat time, right? So there are several high schools that are doing this work exceptionally well, and they are certainly the exception and not the norm, right? 

How are students in high school engaged in things like internships, career-connected learning, and project-based learning, where they’re identifying a problem that they want to solve, and that is a cross-curricular opportunity? It’s not just that they’re sitting in math class and then science class, right? They’re actually doing this work to solve a real problem that engages math and science and ELA and social studies, right, and communications and all of those things at once. But that is a significant shift to what the system is set up to do, right? That’s like a classroom-without-walls kind of approach. 

I think the conditions necessary to be able to ensure at the end of the day that students are carrying that cognitive load mean that we need to support teachers in trusting not just themselves, but also trusting their students that they can, in fact, do this work, and they will rise to the expectations that we set for them. But that does take a lot of effort, and I think it is a change to what is the status quo for any given classroom. 

Lauren: Yeah, I agree. Surprise. 

So what is it that gives you the most hope right now, just right in this moment? Now that we know math anxiety can be tackled at a structural level and that it’s not just resting on the shoulders of individual students who are feeling their feelings in their classrooms, what gives you the most hope about the work that you’re doing and the change that’s happening? 

Hillary: I have great optimism for the future ahead, knowing the district leaders who show up to do this work every single day. 

The National Math Improvement Project is an incredible opportunity to see up close what is happening in these school districts and where the chief academic officers are relentless in their belief that every single student can be successful in their district, and that they will give teachers the support that they need to be able to do this work well. 

I think our community of practice is one that is a genuine community, and even outside of the monthly touchpoints and the opportunities that we create for the districts, they are constantly in communication with each other. 

Think back to when LAUSD was dealing with the Palisades fires and seeing schools that were going to be shut down for weeks, and just the destruction. It still gives me chills to think about what ravaged those communities. 

The leadership called up Chicago Public Schools and said, “Hey, Chicago, we know that you had really incredible resources during COVID that you had pushed out through a blended learning model. Are there things that we can plug in for our students and our system?” 

And those are the things that you can’t plan for, you can’t create. You have to have trust and faith in one another in that shared leadership, and I think we’re now at a point where, yes, there are six individual districts that are all working towards their own goals, but there is a common goal of wanting to support one another, and that will continue, right? 

We’re three years in. We want to continue this work. And even if it’s not in a formal convening, we know that these touchpoints between district leaders will benefit the students across the system and will continue to report out on what’s working to benefit students across the country. 

Lauren: Because I never am actually done asking questions, I have one more question that was sparked by what you said, and it’s actually a thread that we’re kind of tugging at as we continue to have conversations for this particular collection of the podcast. 

Being bad at math — having math anxiety — is really isolating. Justyna and I have had this conversation a lot. We sort of sit alone in our badness at math and start to believe things about ourselves. And one of the reasons, in my opinion, that we wrap our arms around “I’m not a math person” is because it creates community for us. So it creates other people with whom we can be bad at math together or dislike math together. And that’s sort of the remedy, too. Being bad at math allows me to not be a math person, which then puts me in a community, and I’m not alone anymore. 

You talked about the value of community for the National Math Improvement Project. You talked about the value of community for educators, and you talked about the value of community in classrooms, so students having the opportunity to make mistakes and ask questions and think out loud, and work on real-world problems. 

So this is probably a Hillary opinion question, and I love that maybe most of all. 

Why is community so important? Why is community one of the things that we can point to that actually helps districts, leaders, systems, and students change for the better, make changes that have an impact? 

Hillary: In my opinion, the connection and community is really all that matters. 

No problem is going to be solved in complete isolation, no matter what the problem is. I think one of the greatest myths that we’ve told students about math is that math is something that happens while you’re sitting at a desk in silence alone with a paper and pencil. 

That is not how mathematicians or engineers or anyone that’s in STEM works, but more importantly, it’s not how any human works. 

When’s the last time that you were grappling with something and you’re like, “I know how I’ll solve this. I’m going to sit alone and talk about it to myself”? That’s just not how we function, and I think some of what we learned during the pandemic years is that we as humans crave that connection to one another. 

We have the luxury of technology that allows us to have different types of connection and from all over the world, but what it still sometimes takes is that in-person relational connection as well. 

And I think what our community of practice allows for is the real talk of it’s not just what’s happening bright and shiny in our school districts. Of course, we celebrate the successes, but we also know how critically important it is to be honest about the challenges we’re grappling with because the likelihood that they are shared is almost guaranteed. 

And so being able to see, OK, Chicago was able to expand access and maintain success. How can we replicate that as we think of ways for other districts to expand the ways in which they’re identifying students for advanced math courses? 

We know that Houston is saying all principals are going to be the instructional leaders of their building. If that’s what’s going to happen, how do we train principals to know what needs to be done? Those are learnings that can be taken from any district. 

And so I think part of that too is how do we present the good news and the good stories that help us to build that community, right? 

Community can be built around all disliking the same thing, but I actually think it’s much more compelling when we build community around the things that we’re most proud of and the things that can actually help us all grow and learn together. 

 Lauren: That’s beautiful, and so true because being in my I’m not a math person community really didn’t do anything for me positively. 

But joining this community that I’m in now of people who like math has been really, a really great positive impact. So what, what’s left? What do you want to say? What do you want to point to, talk about? What did we miss? What’s important?  

Hillary: Yeah, I think from the state policy perspective. So as I mentioned, prior to Whiteboard Advisors, I was at the Tennessee Department of Education and focused exclusively on state policy. 

I think now, from where I sit, thinking about K–12 across the country and tracking policy momentum, math is certainly having that boost, right? We’ve had the science of reading momentum build and pretty much hit its nexus, right? We have almost every state that has some type of science of reading legislation in place and are ensuring that districts and schools are implementing instructional materials that are evidence-based. 

There is a similar effort in math. However, we can’t talk about science of reading in the same way that we talk about math. Science of reading is really focused on the early grades. When we talk about comprehensive math policy, we need to be thinking about K–12. We actually really need to be thinking K–16.  

We do know what works in math. We might have a smaller evidence base than we do for literacy, but that doesn’t mean that there aren’t evidence-based practices that we know and should be working toward. 

I think there are a handful of states that are really leading in the math space and tackling at least one part of the challenges that lie in ensuring we improve outcomes in K–12 math and prepare students for whatever postsecondary choice they are seeking. 

I think Alabama was arguably the first state to pass a comprehensive math bill with the Numeracy Act, and that was really focused on creating math coaches for schools, especially in the early grades. Now, one of the challenges they ran into is that they didn’t have enough math teachers, nor enough math coaches, right? They’re not alone in that challenge either. 

I think as Kentucky has worked to train more teachers through educator prep programs, but also as they’re in the field, they’re working on that as well. And they actually have a state-created course focused on math to become a math specialist. I’m pretty sure it’s the only state that requires teachers to take a math-specific course in that way. 

As we also see a lot of momentum from last legislative session and this legislative session in the number of math bills, most of them fall into that automatic enrollment policy of ensuring students have access to accelerated coursework and that they are automatically enrolled because we know that opting out of something reduces participation. It’s another barrier to entry that is then eliminated. 

I think where we go next, we need sustained investment in what works in math. We can’t change course because we’re not seeing results fast enough. It took a long time for us to get where we are. 

We can look to the early literacy movement and say, you know, the Mississippi Miracle, as Carey Wright has described it, it’s not a miracle, it’s a marathon, similar to the work that we did in both Tennessee and Louisiana as well. 

It takes time to do this work and see the results. That doesn’t mean we should be letting up on the gas by any means. There are students sitting in classrooms who will go through their whole K–12 experience never having a high-quality math teacher or never not being in a “failing school.” 

That doesn’t mean we let up on the gas, but we do need sustained investment in what works. And that is up to states to make those calls so that districts have the resources they need to be able to implement instructional materials with integrity, ensure every teacher has an instructional coach who has depth of content knowledge in math, and that we are supporting students on this journey to actually enjoy math and courses that are relevant and rigorous to them. 

Lauren: Excellent, OK. 

Hillary: So I guess, yes, I had a little bit to say about policy. 

Lauren: We’re glad! This was excellent, wonderful, everything was amazing. We appreciate it so much.  

Hillary: Thanks, y’all. 

Lauren: So I think the thing that really struck me is we often have conversations about an individual student’s needs or an individual teacher or an individual principal leader. Our focus and our conversations are often around how to help one person or how to help a small subset of a system. 

And what I really appreciated about what Hillary brought to the table and was talking to us about so thoroughly is that it’s actually systems-level, right? So it starts at the top, and it knits itself or folds itself or waterfalls itself down. 

And when we make good decisions as systems leaders and as systems in general, that support — I think she called it the school’s leadership and then the student-facing leadership, right? So when we make good decisions from a systems level, and that can be from the state to the district, those good decisions around what good practice is and looks like and the capacity for our teams to be able to take that on, that trickles down into great principal leaders who are instructional leaders and understand why we’re doing this work. 

And that trickles down to great teachers who are working hard and understand why we’re shifting our practice, why we’re choosing a math curriculum that feels so different from what we’ve been using before, why teaching children not at rows of tables and rows of desks as individuals in their seats, but as classroom communities who engage in problem-solving and mistake-making and digging into not just rote memorization — because there’s value there, we’ve learned that — but also having a deeper understanding of numeracy, of what actually the number four means and how to make it and how to disassemble it and how to reassemble it in different ways. 

And that ultimately — you know, I’m moving my hands a lot; you can’t see it because this is all audio — but that ultimately trickles down into producing student outcomes that are not only improved, but improved across all of our populations of students. 

So everyone has access to high-quality learning because our tippy-top decision-makers are making good and sound decisions about how we support everyone below them and ask for the resources we need from everyone above them. 

So that was a really long answer just to say I appreciate the systems focus. This doesn’t rest on the educator in the classroom. Educators are already carrying such heavy loads, and they’re on cognitive overload at this point. 

I love that we are taking that off their shoulders and saying, “You are absolutely part of the solution, but you’re not the standalone problem in the classroom.” 

We’ve got a lot of work to do before we can really start to get into helping to support better instructional methodology in our rooms and more sound pedagogy. 

So I think that’s probably my biggest takeaway. I also think just the size of the systems that the National Math Improvement Project has been working with, to think about how they have made the moves they’ve made at scale, is impressive. 

This episode of Heart Work is produced by Justyna Welsh, editing by Kristan Crawford, mixing by Fraser Allan. Artwork by Kate Clough. Our series producer and director is Justyna Welsh. Executive producer is David McGinty. Music is from Universal Production Music, and special thanks to Hillary Rinaldi. 

Heart Work is brought to you by Imagine Learning. 

Return to Collection

About the Host

Lauren Keeling is a seasoned education professional with a unique blend of experiences. A former broadcast journalist, elementary teacher, and principal, she now combines her passion for education with her love of storytelling at Imagine Learning. Above all, Lauren is a dedicated literacy advocate pursuing a doctorate in Leadership with a focus on Public and Non-Profit Organizations to further her impact on education nationwide.

An image of Lauren Keeling.

Join the Club

New Paused Pathways Feature in Imagine+ Math

Imagine+ Math

Pause student pathways without losing progress, usage, or reporting data

Districts and educators often need flexibility when placement or instructional plans change during the school year. With the new Paused Pathways feature in Imagine+ Math, educators can temporarily pause a student’s pathway while preserving progress, usage, and reporting data. This update makes it easier to manage instructional changes without disrupting student records or historical data. 

Learn More
New Paused Pathways Feature in Imagine Plus Math

Quick Score Saves Grading Time in Imagine IM®

Imagine IM

Enter scores faster with streamlined grading tools and automatic saving 

Quick Score helps teachers spend less time on manual score entry. Educators can enter scores directly from the assignment view, use min/max buttons to speed up grading, and move between students with automatic saving built in. When manual scoring is needed, Quick Score provides a faster, simpler way to complete grading tasks and keep instruction moving forward. Now available for all Imagine Learning Classroom teachers and administrators. 

Learn More
Quick Score Saves Grading Time in Imagine IM 

Improved Slide Editing in Imagine IM®

Imagine IM

Edit lesson slides directly in the lesson player with fewer clicks and less disruption

Based on educator feedback, lesson customization is now faster and more intuitive. Teachers can edit slide text, notes, and voiceover scripts directly within the lesson player; stay on the same slide while making changes; and manage slide order from the thumbnail view. This update simplifies lesson adjustments and helps teachers tailor instruction more efficiently for their students. Available June 1 for all Imagine Learning Classroom teachers and administrators. 

Learn More
Improved Slide Editing in Imagine IM 

LiveLearn Student Response Grid Now Available

Imagine IM

See classwide student responses in real time and adjust instruction as learning happens

Teachers need quick visibility into student thinking during instruction. The new Student Response Grid in LiveLearn displays responses from the entire class in a single view, making it easier to identify misconceptions, incomplete work, or disengagement as they occur. With real-time insights, teachers can adjust pacing, prompts, discussion, and support to keep learning on track. Available June 1 for all Imagine Learning Classroom teachers and administrators. 

Learn More
Improved Slide Editing in Imagine IM 

Professional Learning That Fits Your Schedule

Imagine Professional Learning

Flexible new learning options designed for how educators engage today  

As districts prepare for back to school, Imagine Learning is expanding professional learning opportunities to better support both new and returning educators. New Community Learning Sessions, self-paced courses, and subscription access for select products provide more flexible ways to engage in learning — whether educators are getting started, refreshing their knowledge, or deepening implementation. Built around shared outcomes and consistent, high-quality content, these new offerings make it easier to scale support across your district and strengthen implementation all year long. 

Learn More
Professional Learning That Fits Your Schedule 

Breaking the Cycle of Math Anxiety

Listen on Spotify
Listen on Apple Podcasts

Building Thinking Classrooms with Peter Liljedahl 

In this Heart Work special, Lauren Keeling and Sam Murro Shea sit down with math education pioneer and creator of Building Thinking Classrooms Peter Liljedahl to explore what happens when math classrooms stop rewarding students for simply getting the right answer and start helping them truly think — and how the right experiences can transform math anxiety into confidence. 

From Imagine Learning, I’m Lauren Keeling and you’re listening to Heart Work — an honest profile of America’s educators. 

Lauren Keeling (to Peter): When students get to experience a thinking classroom that very first time, what do you see happen in that room? 

Peter Liljedahl: A cacophony of emotions. I start with a task that every single student can do so that when they’re walking away from the launch, they’re already feeling like, “I got this.” 

Lauren (to Sam): Sam, I am so excited because our listeners are about to tap into a conversation with Peter Liljedahl, who is a genius. 

Sam Murro Shea: I mean, yes, genius and mathematician and researcher, all of the above. He’s kind of run the gamut. And why I’m so excited to talk to him is because he had a really interesting start to mathematics. I, of course, listening to different podcasts and talking with him at conferences and listening to him at conferences, definitely reading his books, right, I feel like his journey is really important for us to talk about how he came to discover these 14 different practices. 

Lauren: I love it. 

Sam: So today we’re here with Peter Liljedahl, and I should probably start by explaining how I know Peter, mostly because it involves lines. I was working in a school district as a math director, and I found Peter Liljedahl’s work by reading Building Thinking Classrooms during COVID. What a wild time that was to be in education. And I remember thinking, “This is exactly the lens principals and teachers need if we want problem-solving in math to actually be accessible to students.” That book shifted how I thought about classrooms, not just curriculum, but really the conditions under which students are asked to think. Then came the math conferences, where I truly spent an unreasonable amount of time standing in long hallway lines just to hear about these 14 practices and a more in-depth story about Peter’s journey. Peter Liljedahl, hi. 

Peter: Wow. It seems like you and I have been in a relationship much longer than I thought. 

Sam: We have been — for years, for many years. 

Peter: OK, well, it’s nice to finally meet you. 

Sam: You, as well. 

Lauren: It’s so nice to be in this space. And Peter, I don’t know that I have ever heard a better introduction or welcome to a meeting or a gathering than I just did from Sam. Sam, that was so lovely. 

Peter: I have to agree. I have to agree. 

Lauren: So nice. So nice. My name is Lauren. As explained before, I am deeply an ELA person. That is my heart and my spirit. Also, I am deeply a person who suffers from math anxiety and math trauma. So I am entering this meeting with you today, Peter, very curious. Sam has opened up my brain and my mind to the ways with which you are asking teachers and administrators to think about their classrooms, and I think that’s really lovely and very fascinating. And I picture myself in those spaces as a child and how that may have changed how I felt about math even today as a 42-year-old woman. So the thing I’m entering with curiosity today, I want you to share your knowledge with us. The very first thing I need to know is what were you seeing in these math classrooms that you were visiting that made you feel like something needed to change, and that was Building Thinking Classrooms? 

Peter: Well, I don’t think you have to be me to be in a math classroom to see that something needs to change, right? 

I was in classrooms yesterday. Anytime you’re in a classroom with students, you can sense that there is an unease. There is a disquiet, right? And there’s a discordance. There’s a discordance between the goals of the teacher and the actions of the students, right? The teacher has the best of intentions for the students. 

They really want these students to do well. The students maybe are not equally motivated to do well. But what I was seeing in particular wasn’t that students weren’t performing — and I mean on tests. It wasn’t that students were unhappy, or uncomfortable, or uneasy. 

That is almost a status quo around the world. It was that they weren’t thinking. Now that wasn’t something that became clear to me right away, right? Because there is a lot of noise in a classroom. And by noise, I mean noise that a researcher would notice, right? There’s a lot of movement,  there’s a lot of discordance between goals, there’s a lot of amotivation. 

There’s a lot of what I eventually came to call “studenting,” which is what students do to kind of get through the lesson. There’s a lot of that stuff that can really distract and draw your attention away from what’s going on. But it was when I finally noticed that what was missing for these students was thinking. 

They were engaged in lots of activity, and this activity was keeping them busy, but it wasn’t requiring them to think, at least not in ways we know students need to think in order to continue to be successful in mathematics. There was a lot of note-taking. There was some group work, but there was a huge emphasis on mimicking. 

And mimicking is that sort of, “I’m going to show you how to do it, now you just do it.” And what I actually found when I was engaging with these students who were engaged in mimicking was that mimicking is not really a thinking activity, right? It’s not a learning activity. It’s what I eventually came to call a production activity. 

Mimicking is what students do to produce for their teacher the things that the teacher wants in exchange for praise, gold stars, and grades, right? So that’s what I was seeing. I was seeing a lot of behaviors that were not thinking behaviors, and then I was seeing very little, if any, thinking. 

Lauren: I hear you make so many fascinating points. Mimicking is not truly learning; it’s performing and showing you what I know, or what you know that you have now imparted onto me that I’m mimicking back to you. 

So I’m thinking about this moment where you said that the classroom is kind of uncomfortable anyway. That’s the nature of learning and the nature of grappling with information. So my wonder is, sometimes we connect being anxious in the classroom to being uncomfortable in the classroom, and ultimately not wanting to be seen struggling in the classroom. 

So how does building a thinking classroom change what it feels like to struggle or grapple in front of others? 

Peter: So this is actually a really interesting question because some of the key features of a thinking classroom, for example, is you’re going to be put into random groups. So now you’re immediately thrust in front of peers. You’re going to be standing and working at a vertical whiteboard, so now you’re visible to everybody. And so you would think that this actually makes them feel more visible, which could increase anxiety, but it turned out it actually did the opposite. So first of all, when they’re standing at the whiteboards, everyone’s standing at the whiteboards, and everyone is focused on their work. No one’s really looking at how you’re doing. 

Now, that may not be something they’re aware of to begin with, but they certainly settle on that very quickly. And they start to realize that this whiteboard is an incredibly — although it is publicly available — private space, right? That we’re working here because everyone is working, and if I do need to tap into some knowledge that’s out there, I just have to look around the room, and I can grab some other ideas from other people. 

But not in that sort of sense that I’m being put on display, OK? And in fact, teachers have really commented on this, and students have commented on this as well, is that, you know, at first it felt like it was sort of I was being outed, but then I realized that, no, this is an incredibly safe space to work. 

In terms of working with others, so one of the things that sort of normative classrooms have done is that they’ve normalized this idea that you’re supposed to be getting it, right? So that the teacher’s going to tell kids how to do things, and the students are supposed to get it. And if you can’t get it, you are the outlier, right? 

So now here’s a student, and I always say one of the worst experiences a student can have is to be sitting in a classroom where they perceive that everybody else understands, and they’re the only one that isn’t understanding. Now, that’s rarely true, but truth, reality, and perception are very different, right? 

It’s what the student perceives that is their reality. So if they perceive that they’re the only one who’s not getting it, then that would be a horrible experience, right? And it would increase anxiety. But in a thinking classroom, what’s normalized is that we’re not getting it, right? 

We’re persevering, we’re persisting, we’re trying to figure it out. We’re working towards understanding. It’s not that understanding is just bestowed on us. So this is not to say that there’s an unleashed sort of exploratory space. It’s very directed, and it’s very controlled and guided. 

But the students aren’t… Really, what’s normal is that we don’t know what the answer is. And when students are in a space where everybody is working hard to understand, then all of a sudden what used to be an outlier becomes the normative structure. And one of the things I always say is that in a thinking classroom, what we want to create is a space where not knowing is a normal and an accepted state to be in, and then the students work towards getting out of that. 

And then they figure something out, and then here comes the next challenge, and it’s a little bit harder, and they’re working together. And it’s that togetherness that makes it safer. It’s that we are working towards this. I don’t own all of this myself.  

 So that’s just part of it. There’s so much more around that. But one of the things that students really talk about in these spaces is how safe they feel. 

Lauren: You really spoke to seven-year-old Lauren in that moment, who felt like the outlier, the only one in the room who wasn’t getting it, sitting in her seat in the row of her students, watching everybody scribble furiously when I wanted to lay my head down on the table and cry. 

Yeah. So I deeply hear… What a horrible experience. A terrible experience, truly, and not for my teacher’s lack of trying. She wanted to do the best by her students, but she taught the way she knew. 

So my wonder, Peter, is when students get to experience a thinking classroom that very first time, and those who are like me, who had that moment where they felt like they were alone and the only one not getting it, what emotional shift — what do you see happen in that room? 

Peter: So the very first time they experience a thinking classroom is a sort of cacophony of emotions, I would say. So for students who like math, this is exciting, right? 

This is, oh, this is going to be new. This is going to be interesting, right? For students who are really good at mimicking, and that’s how they actually get by, this could be a little uncomfortable, right? What do you mean you’re not going to show me how to do this first, right? For a student who is anxious, this could be really terrifying to begin with. 

And I’m not going to deny that, but I think that’s true of any time a student walks into a classroom that has an unpredictable environment, right? Because if they’re anxious, what’s triggering for them is, I’m going to be put in front of people. I’m not going to know what’s going on, and so on and so forth. 

Because what we have to understand is that seven-year-old Lauren’s experience has lodged itself in your memory and in your emotions. And what’s coming forward is that trauma, right? So when you’re told you’re going to take a card, and you’re going to go to a board, and you’re going to work with people, you’re imagining and remembering the worst collaborative experience you ever had. 

When I’m sending you to a whiteboard, what you’re not thinking about is the fact that everyone’s at the whiteboard. You’re thinking about that time that you had to go up and do something on the whiteboard in front of everybody else, and you got laughed at, right? These are triggers to begin with. 

I admit that. But what happens very quickly after that first moment is that the student starts to realize that this is not that. This is not that group experience that I had back in second grade. This is not that time in fifth grade where I had to stand in front of the whiteboard by myself. 

But these emotions can come forward, I’m not denying that. Which is why when we start to build a thinking classroom, we have to be super, super careful, right? Like, what a thinking classroom looks like on day one is very different from what it looks like on day ten, which is very different from what it looks like on day fifty, right? 

So yesterday, I was in classrooms with students. It’s the end of January. They’ve been in thinking classrooms since August, right? These students are not fazed by taking a card and going to a whiteboard and getting going on a difficult trig problem or an algebra problem, right? They are not fazed by that because this is a normal state for them. 

But on that first day, we have to be really, really careful. Now, one of the things that we learned in our research is that students don’t really listen to what we say as teachers, right? So, it doesn’t really matter what I say prior to this. You are being flooded by your emotions and your memories, and I’m not going to be able to talk you out of your emotions, right? 

So what we have to do is very quickly just get them into the experience, but the experience has to be really, really positive. So what we do is we are very careful in the tasks that we pick on those first few days. So we start with what’s called a non-curricular task. So a non-curricular task is clearly mathematics, but also clearly not what we’re teaching. 

And what that does is it really lowers the stakes of this experience, because now this is not something I have to learn. It’s not something I have to remember. It’s not something that is going to be on the test. So I can stop worrying about that. Now, that doesn’t solve all your anxieties, but it’s going to eliminate some. 

The task has to be fun, right? So it’s got to pull you in so it feels more playful than actual math, and it has to have a low floor. And what that means is that every single student in the room should feel like they can start, right? And if that happens, if we put all of those pieces together, then Lauren, who’s going to take that card and go to the board, is going to have an idea on how to start right away. 

The random groups have taken away the stigma that comes with that social interaction. I wasn’t excluded. I wasn’t included. It just is the way it is. 

Peter: So how we start is super, super important, right? 

We’re just starting to try to build a culture within the room, a culture of thinking. I’m normalizing this behavior and this experience without high stakes. Students by and large don’t dislike group work. They dislike being in a dysfunctional group. So we work a lot on trying to make sure that those groups are functional and that they’re positive experiences for the students. 

And we do this actually not just for one day. We do it for three to five days in a row because students can’t learn a pattern of behavior from one experience. They need to have repeated experiences like this. 

We have to be careful. If we have a really anxious student, we have to onboard them really gently. 

So one of the ways that I onboard a really anxious student — and let’s be clear, a highly anxious student is not always visible to us, right? Because in a very traditional teaching setting, that student who sits in the third desk in the fourth row, keeps their head down, takes really beautiful notes, does all their homework, never raises their hand but always seems to know what the answer is, keeps to themselves, may actually have an undiagnosed anxiety disorder. 

But regardless, when this student presents themselves as highly anxious, one of the ways that I onboard them is that I don’t force them to interact on that first day. I do require them to go to their group. They can stand like six feet back. And I actually give them a job. I say, “OK. Your job is to go spy on your group. 

You don’t have to contribute. You don’t have to hold a pen. But I want you to stay there for five minutes and then come and tell me what it is that they’re saying.” And then they come up to you, and they tap you on the shoulder, and you’re like, “OK, yeah, tell me.” And you have to be super interested in that moment. 

And then as they tell you what’s going on, you just have to be so fascinated by this. And like, “You’re kidding. What’s happening next? Oh, can you go give me another five minutes and come and tell me what happens next?” And you just keep doing this, right? And the second day you do the same thing, and the third day you do the same thing. 

And we’ve done this on a number of occasions, and our conversion rate on this is absolutely incredible. Within seven days, there’s a 95 percent chance that this student is going to say something to their group. Because what’s going to happen is there’s that perfect storm. That student hasn’t been pushed, but all of a sudden they’re in a group where they feel safe, and they know something, and then they’re going to say something. 

And the minute they say something, that bubble is burst, and within three days they’re holding the marker, and four weeks later you can’t tell the difference between this student and any other student in the room, right? We didn’t allow them to opt out, but we sort of gently enabled them to opt in. 

But that wouldn’t have happened if I didn’t have that sort of warm demander requirement that they be at their board so that they can pay attention to what’s going on 

 Sam: Treating kids like people, giving them a space that is comfortable. You’re still asking them the same requirements, right? But you’re taking the task and making sure that they feel confident to at least begin the task. How does this model really support teachers through their discomfort and through their anxiety? 

Peter:  So Building Thinking Classrooms is a collection of 14 practices. And it’s a framework where it looks at those 14 practices. It turns out that those 14 practices self-organize into four toolkits. This is empirical. 

Four toolkits, and the idea is we start with the first toolkit, and we work with those practices. And then when we’re done in the first toolkit, we move to the second toolkit, and we work with those practices, and so on and so forth. So it’s developmental. Now, it turns out to be developmental for the students and the teachers. So it’s developmental for the students because, you know, this could be their very first experience in this sort of a setting. So it starts them off in a way that’s comfortable and easy to enter into, and then it demands more and more of them as we go, right? But not all at once. 

They have to become encultured into this system of thinking, and then to be learning through thinking, and then letting go of some of those anxieties and beliefs and shifting their identity. 

It’s developmental for teachers because we can’t take on that much change all at once. And even if we could, the kids would explode from too much change. So it’s developmental in the sense that we’re going to start off in the things that are good for the kids, and then we’re adding one practice at a time. 

And I like to think of it sort of as a replacement theory, in the sense that you don’t just throw out all of your practices and then implement Building Thinking Classrooms, right? You want to change the way you’re doing notes, for example, that’s not until toolkit number three. You can keep doing notes the way you’re currently doing, right? 

You’re not going to throw that out. Homework, same thing. That’s also toolkit three. The way we assess, that changes, but that’s not until toolkit four. Until then, you have to still assess the way you normally do. So you start with your current practice. You make a change for toolkit one, but you keep everything else going. 

You’re going to start to find incongruencies between your sort of older self and the newer self that’s emerging. And that sort of helps you move forward, that incongruency, because you’re feeling like, OK, there’s a tension here, and then you’re like, “Oh, now I get to replace that,” and that creates more synergy and so on and so forth. 

But it is developmental. But in terms of setup for toolkit number one is a thinking task. If you want students to think, you have to give them something to think about, so you have to start with a thinking task, right? So you have to have some of those. Good news: I have lots, and you can have them. 

They’re on my website. They’re in the books. There you go. Number two, you’re going to need random groups. That takes a deck of cards. It’s actually the easiest practice to implement. It’s the cheapest. It has the biggest impact. It’s also the one that scares us the most because it marks the biggest shift in control, right? 

We’re going to have to get the kids up to vertical whiteboards. Now, this seems like an expensive endeavor. It doesn’t have to be, right? It doesn’t have to be a whiteboard. It just has to be vertical and erasable. So writing on a window works. By the way, kids love that, right? And then you need to be willing to talk to them about what the difference is between turn-taking and collaborating and working on how do we actually get collaboration to be something that is integrated, where we’re talking to each other, we’re sharing the load, and so on and so forth. 

And then we just go for it, right? And we’re not going to be experts at it. The second time we do it is way better than the first, but not nearly as good as the third. And you are immediately going to see things in your students that you want more of. 

Sam: What led you to choose these four practices that make up Building Thinking Classrooms? And which do you think are the most influential when it comes to reducing math anxiety for students? 

Peter: OK. So the 14 are actually responses to 14 variables. So I actually spent a lot of time in classrooms, in normative classrooms, just watching what teachers do and just, kind of, cataloging what they do. 

And that catalog reduced down to 14 practices. These are the 14 things that everybody does, more or less. If you’re a kindergarten teacher, you’re not necessarily having your kids write notes, but for the most part, we’re doing these 14 practices, right? 

So, for example, every teacher uses tasks. I don’t care who you are, you use tasks. Every teacher uses collaborative groups to some extent, some more than others. We have to give students a workspace. We have to arrange the furniture in our room. We answer questions. We have students do homework, right? We launch tasks. We do all of these things, right? 

And so these 14 practices account for anywhere between 90 and 100 percent of what a teacher does on a day-to-day basis, right? So these became sort of what I call the central practices that every teacher does, and then that became a variable, right? 

So, for example, let’s take groups, right? Every teacher does collaborative groups to some extent. Well, so what are the most normative ways that teachers do that? Well, one is we create strategic groups, which is that I have a goal, and I’m going to use that goal to guide the formation of these groups, and I’m going to really carefully make these groups, right? 

So maybe I want to differentiate today, so I’m going to make ability groups. Or maybe I want to increase productivity, so I’ll make mixed-ability groups. Or maybe I just want peace and quiet, so I’m going to keep certain students apart, right? But whatever my goal is, I’m going to make the groups very carefully. This is a dominant grouping strategy of elementary teachers, right? 

So I started with the core routines that every teacher does and then made that a variable, looked at the status quo, then iterated to improve. Almost every single time, the practice that emerged as the most effective for getting students to think was radically different from the sort of normative routines that we tend to use. 

Now, which one actually has the biggest impact on reducing anxiety? 

Ironically, I think it’s random groups. It makes a really safe space, but it can’t just be random groups on its own. It has to be random groups coupled with the teacher’s work to make sure that the groups are functional and that there is respect and empathy and so on and so forth. 

And to that end, we also work on these things called empathy boosters. So none of these things just work out of the package, right? You still have to bring all your teacherly craft to it. 

I think another one that actually works well at reducing anxiety is chapter nine, which is what’s called thin slicing. So thin slicing is how I start with a task that every single student can do, right? So that when they’re walking away from the launch, they’re already feeling like, “I got this.” 

And then we work our way… The task gets a little bit harder and a little bit harder, and they’re still feeling in control. “Yeah, this is good. I got this. I got this. I got this.” And then on question number six or seven, they’re kind of like, “OK, here it is.” 

And it’s like you hear it in the student. And then they enter into a state that we call productive struggle. Now, everybody talks about productive struggle, but one of the things that we really learned about productive struggle is if all we do is challenge our students, they’re more likely to give up than to enter into a state of productive struggle. 

But if we challenge our students on the heels of success, then they’re more likely to go into a state of productive struggle. So it’s not challenge them. It’s I’m going to have you have some success, success, success, success, here comes a challenge. 

And in that guided way, they’re feeling really safe, so that by the time they’re actually working hard and actually thinking and collaborating because they need each other, they are so full of confidence. 

We’re not just throwing these kids to the wolves. We are completely present, making sure that these experiences are positive. 

But the best thing that we could ever achieve in a classroom is when the students have walked out, and they feel like they succeeded, and they figured it out on their own. And our fingerprints are all over that, right? 

Like, we manufactured this completely, but they feel like they’re on top of the world because they did it. 

Sam: I absolutely love that because you really hit a couple of things really hard. It’s not just about making sure that the kids are thinking but really changing how they feel about mathematics. I love that. I love how we also talked about teachers and their role and responsibility. 

What about school leaders or administrators observing a thinking classroom? What should they be looking for maybe at the beginning of just starting Building Thinking Classrooms with some of the practices the teachers will be engaging with versus the end? 

Peter: Well, first of all, an administrator should know enough about Building Thinking Classrooms to know what to look for. They don’t have to be the expert. The classroom teacher can be the expert. But they can provide that sort of guidance and that feedback as to what they’re seeing. 

Early on, what they should see the teacher doing is having the courage to try these things, right? And to become comfortable with their imperfections around this. And the teacher and the administrator can provide the feedback for that. 

And it’s really a sandbox, right? The teacher’s trying to find that space. One of the things the administrator can help them do is to stay focused on the original Building Thinking Classroom practices. 

So Building Thinking Classrooms is 14 macro moves, right? It’s 14 practices, but each one comes with dozens of micro moves, these little nuances that make it go better. And teachers are going to want to bring their own in, and I think that’s really important. But they should at least try some of the things that are in the book so they’ve got a baseline data, right? 

Like, try this. Do it this way. Do it like that for a while. Get a baseline. How well is this working? Now, if you want to iterate on that, if you want to innovate, you can do that. But now you can actually have something to measure as to whether or not that’s actually better or not. 

What it looks like three months later: the teacher should be more confident, the students should be more comfortable, and the teacher should be able to be much more focused on curriculum. They’re still using the curriculum to guide what it is they have to teach, but they’re not being controlled by the pacing guide anymore. 

So that’s the sort of thing they should be looking for because that is going to allow the teacher to respond best to what the needs of the students are, right? 

We’re saving time in some places, and we’re using that time in other places. 

Lauren: I want to know, Peter, your last thoughts. We have run the gamut. We have talked about every possible thing and person that could have their hands on and in a math classroom. So what do you want to leave us with today? What do you want us to walk away with or know or… 

Peter: It’s really important to remember that Building Thinking Classrooms is a framework, right? It’s a collection of 14 practices that are meant to guide teachers in creating thinking classrooms. It is not some sort of choreographed dance that only I hold the choreography to, right? 

 I’m helping you get in the sandbox. I’m helping you get in there. I’m giving you tools to help you get students thinking, and as a byproduct of that, reduce anxiety and change their experiences and change their beliefs about what math is and who their future self is within mathematics. 

Sam: Well, as an educator, I’m always willing to learn new things and try new things. I would just like to say thank you, because what this book provided for me, reflecting back on everything that I’ve done and tried in the classroom, you know, people would ask me all the time, “Why does this work? What are you doing?” And I couldn’t name it, and you brought the names to what I was doing. 

But I could never describe or tell people what I was doing, or if I did, they told me I was crazy, right, for trying something completely non-traditional, but it made my students love coming to my classroom. So it really validated the work that I have done, even though I think sometimes as a teacher when we look back, you’re like, “Ah, I should’ve done this differently. I should’ve done this differently.” But you really validated some of the things that I was willing to try for my students to make sure that everybody was successful. 

Peter: One of the things that you said there really kind of encapsulates this whole conversation because we’ve been talking about students and student, right? 

So we’ve been talking about students as a whole, like what is the best thing we can do as a teacher for our class as a whole, while at the same time being mindful of those individuals who may need a little bit more care and attention, right? 

And that is also Building Thinking Classrooms, right? It is not something that is applied blindly to all our students. We apply that sort of holistic method, and then we make adaptations and modifications for certain students to help them get on the train and start to have these positive experiences as well. 

Lauren: And I think that’s where my gratitude comes from today, Peter. Going back to being seven-year-old Lauren, I’m just so grateful for the work that you’re doing in stripping away the shame of struggle for children in classrooms. I’m just so grateful that that work is happening and encouraged. 

Peter: My pleasure. It’s one of the things that drives me forward every day. 

Sam: That was phenomenal and amazing. 

Yeah. Well, I’m curious, like if you, going all those years back in school, even seven-year-old little Lauren, what’s one of his practices that would’ve changed maybe the way you felt about mathematics? 

Lauren: He said it so many times, but just that collaborative grouping and front-of-the-room struggle. 

So it truly did reach deep down inside of my spirit when he was talking about the child sitting in the third seat in the fourth row who did her homework, who knew the answers. I could answer the questions, but I never felt successful. I was never confident in being right. And because at that time in education, we were doing our work alone at our desks, or any time that we walked up to the board to use chalk, in my day, to use chalk on the chalkboard was for a timed experience. 

So I was racing against another child to answer a multiplication question or a division question or an addition or subtraction question, even for seven-year-old me. And there’s a lot of stress and anxiety in that simply because I knew that I didn’t know the answer right away. 

So that’s a long way, a long road to get to using that collaborative grouping, removing the shame of individual struggle, and inviting students to work together and recognize that we’re all figuring it out. 

Somebody may know the right answer, but their ability to share how they got there with me could open it up. 

Sam: Yes. And reflecting on that, you know what’s so fascinating is all of those teaching principles within his book, Building Thinking Classrooms, those are things we do as adults when we work in groups to solve problems anyway, right? 

And maybe they’re not these high-leverage math tasks. But working in these collaborative groups, and you might be pulling people from different departments. You always have that whiteboard in your conference room when you come together and work. And so these are things that we do naturally as adults that now we’re pushing into the classroom, which really, I guess, humanizes the math experience. 

Lauren: You know, that’s a beautiful point. And the other practice that he talked about that — I love that phrase, “humanizes the math experience” — the other practice that he spoke about that I think, one, would have impacted my own classroom but also me as a student is doing something fun. Math was never fun, ever. At least in my memory. Somebody may have been having fun, but it was not me. 

Sam: Oh, I wish you were in my math class. 

Lauren: Me too, Sam. Actually, can I come to your math class? Would you teach, would you do a math class for me? 

Sam: That is my favorite thing, yes. It’s the light bulb moments that really make me keep wanting to teach people. 

Lauren: We may have to go back to seven-year-old-style math. I think we should do it. 

Sam: Would love to. I think it would be such a fun time. 

 This episode of Heart Work is produced and edited by Danny McPadden, mixing by Fraser Allan. Artwork by Kate Clough. Our series producer and director is Justyna Welsh. Executive producer is David McGinty. Music is from Universal Production Music. Special thanks to Peter Liljedahl and my colleague, Sam Murro Shea. Heart Work is brought to you by Imagine Learning. 

Return to Collection

About the Host

Lauren Keeling is a seasoned education professional with a unique blend of experiences. A former broadcast journalist, elementary teacher, and principal, she now combines her passion for education with her love of storytelling at Imagine Learning. Above all, Lauren is a dedicated literacy advocate pursuing a doctorate in Leadership with a focus on Public and Non-Profit Organizations to further her impact on education nationwide.

An image of Lauren Keeling.

Join the Club